First 10 buyers pay half.First 10 buyers pay half. See the tools

Home / Holiday let hosts / Reply to a bad guest review without making it worse

Reply to a bad guest review without making it worse

The problem:
A guest left a bad review and I am afraid of making it worse in public.
What you get back:
A public reply that is true as it stands, a private message to the guest where it helps, and a to-do list.
Get it, $15$15 $7.50 for the first 10 buyers. 30-day refund.

UK and EU buyers see local prices; VAT is added at checkout.

Tried on 4 real public reviews and 2 made-up reviews. Read every reply before you post.

How it works in 3 steps

  1. Install the skill in Claude, ChatGPT or your assistant (how to install).
  2. Give it the review and what really happened.
  3. Read the reply, then post it.

Also in the pack: All 6 host tools, $29

See it run

A short screen recording of ChatGPT's free version, logged out: the review reply instruction and an invented guest review are pasted in, and a calm public reply, a private message and a to-do list come back.
The finished reply from a real run in ChatGPT's free version, 6 Oct 2026. The review is invented. Not edited.
Read the full reply
Review 1: critical · Flags: MONEY, POLICY Reply (42 words) Thank you for staying with us and for your feedback. You found the heating not working on your first night. The heating was working again by 11am the next morning. We are sorry that this part of your stay was not better for you. Add if true We were in touch with you during your stay. Private message to the guest (38 words) Thank you for your stay and for the detail in your messages. I have confirmed that the heating was working again by 11am the next morning. I am sorry the stay went this way for you, and I appreciate you taking the time to explain your experience. What to fix (private, not for posting) Check and correct the listing so the photos and description accurately represent the flat and the partial sea view. Check whether the description of the pedestrian street with bars is sufficiently clear. Check whether the street noise needs further review. Check whether whoever cleans is checking the bin before arrival. Keep the message log and engineer confirmation as evidence. Before you post Because the review contains abusive language and a threat concerning a bank dispute, consider asking Booking.com to review it under its reviews policy. Do not decide or discuss the money issue in the public reply; the platform's own process is where a money claim is settled. If considering any legal response to the threat, get advice before posting. Read it once more before posting, and treat the reply as permanent.

Before and after

A 1-star Booking.com review, partly unfair. It calls the host a scammer, demands a full refund and threatens a bank dispute. Host's notes: heating fixed by 11am the next morning, no refund agreed, unsure about the bin.

Before: a defensive reply (written by us to show the trap)

"We are sorry you feel this way. You said we never answered, but we replied at 8:10am. The listing clearly says partial sea view and a street with bars."

After: real output, unedited

"Thank you for staying with us and for taking the time to share your feedback. You found the heating was not working on your first night at the flat. The engineer had the heating working again by 11am the following morning. We are sorry your stay was not better and thank you for telling us."

One issue named, the one confirmed fix, and no refund demand, bank dispute, "scammer" or bin.

What it does

Paste a guest review and what you know about what happened. You get the public reply to post under it, a private message to the guest, and a note on what to fix. The reply is written for the people who read it next: future guests. It is true as it stands, because it never claims a fix you have not made and never speaks for you beyond thanks, acknowledgement and apology.

Good to know

Free updates: when we improve it, you get the new version.

Will it make things up? It uses only the review and your notes. It never promises a fix or a refund you have not made.

$15 once, no monthly fee. Review software such as Reviewflowz starts at £40 a location a month (Pro, billed yearly, their pricing page) and connects to your listings. This does not: you paste a review and get a reply.

A skill you install once (works in Claude, ChatGPT and other assistants), a short guide, and a paste-in version if your plan has no skills.

Test notes

TESTED badge. Run on at least three real examples and scored against a written standard, with the record on file.4 real public reviews on an earlier version, 2 made-up ones on this version.

We tried it on two made-up reviews: a mixed one on Vrbo, and a harsh, partly unfair one on Booking.com with a refund demand. Each came with the host's private notes. We ran them in Claude and in ChatGPT's free version, and read every reply for invented facts, promises and private details. Claude came back clean on both after one fix. ChatGPT's free version is clean on money and insults, but still has two small flaws, so read every reply before you post. No host has used it on a live listing yet.

More on how it was tested

An earlier version argued about reply times, wrote what the guest "expected" and, in ChatGPT's free version, put an unsure fact and a payment line in public. We fixed the rules and ran the harsh review again. What is left in ChatGPT's free version is a faint rebuttal about the reply time and a paraphrase of the guest's complaint, and on the mixed review it dropped two complaints. A later round shortened the reply to four short sentences about one main issue. ChatGPT's free version then wrote 38 and 41 words in that shape, though on the mixed review it named two kitchen items and its fix did not match the issue. Two reviews, one run each: a small test.

Limits

  • It knows only what the review says and what you tell it. It cannot check what happened.
  • Airbnb states that a host's response is posted immediately and shown with the review. We have not confirmed whether a response can be edited later. Treat it as permanent and read it before you post.
  • For reviews about injury, illness, discrimination or legal threats it gives a holding reply and tells you what to check. That is not legal advice.
  • An earlier version sometimes wrote in the wrong voice, for example as if the host were part of a group. The rules now rule that out, and our re-run did not do it. Still, read every reply before you post.
  • It does not guarantee results.

Questions

How do I pay and get the files?

Checkout: Gumroad opens on this page. Click Add to cart, enter your email and card details, and check the total, with any VAT, before you pay. Prices here are in US dollars.

After you pay: a download page opens right away with the zip file, and Gumroad gives you a receipt there that you can resend. Open it, then paste the text from the prompts folder into ChatGPT and add your details.

Refunds and contact

If it does not do the job, ask and we refund you within 30 days. Reply to your receipt, or use the contact page.

Contact page

Which assistants does it work with?

Works in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and most other AI assistants: paste in the text, or load the files if your assistant supports them. Setup steps are under For technical users. We run our release tests on Claude. Use your assistant's strongest model: in our tests, a small, fast model added facts that were not in the source data. No scripts and no web access needed: it works from what you paste.

For technical users

What is in the zip

Using it with an AI assistant

  1. Unzip the download. It holds the guest-review-reply folder, ready-made zips for claude.ai in a claude-ai folder, a README and the licence.
  2. Put the guest-review-reply folder where your assistant looks for skills. The generic path is .agents/skills/ (or npx skills add from a folder). Tool-specific paths:
    • Claude Code: ~/.claude/skills/ (or .claude/skills/ inside one project)
    • OpenAI Codex, Gemini CLI, Cursor and others: .agents/skills/ or the skills folder their docs name
    • claude.ai: Customize, Skills, then the plus button, Create skill, Upload a skill, and upload the zip from the claude-ai folder without unzipping it (code execution must be on in Settings, Capabilities)
    • ChatGPT or any chatbot: open the skill's prompt.md, paste it into the chat, then paste your own text or link
    • Steps for each tool, with links to its official docs: how to install skills
  3. Ask for the job in plain words, for example: "A guest left this review and I don't know how to respond. Site: Airbnb. My notes: ... Review: ...". The skill loads by itself.
Get it, $15

Jobs that go with this