Managing people / How to talk to an employee about a mistake: 16 questions and opening lines, by moment (2026)

How to talk to an employee about a mistake: 16 questions and opening lines, by moment (2026)

Free. Not legal or HR advice.

Short answer

Talk in private, soon, and start with the facts. Ask what happened without blame, then ask what they need to put it right.

Last checked: . Written and tested by Pro Skill Packs: how we test.

13 questions you can copy

Sixteen questions and opening lines: eight basic ones, then eight for the moment you open, how you respond, and how you close. Speak in private, stick to the facts, and speak to HR before anything formal.

Jump to: Eight basic linesOpening for different mistakesResponding and closing

Questions about a mistake

  • What happened, in your own words?
  • What did you notice at the time?
  • What would you do differently next time?
  • What do you need in order to put it right?
  • What help do you want from me?

Three ways to open

  • I want to talk about what happened in [MEETING OR EMAIL]. First: how are you?
  • I looked at [PIECE OF WORK]. I want to show you what I saw, and hear what you think.
  • The [TASK] was due on [DATE] and it came on [DATE]. I want to understand what happened.

More examples, by situation

Opening for different mistakes

  • A missed deadlineThe [TASK] was due on [DATE]. I want to understand what made it hard to finish on time.
  • An error in a documentI found [WHAT] on page [PAGE] of [DOCUMENT]. Can we go through it together?
  • A mistake with a customerI read the reply that went to [CUSTOMER]. I would like to hear how you saw it.
  • A mistake that cost money[WHAT HAPPENED] cost [AMOUNT OR TIME]. I want to understand it, not to blame. Walk me through it.

Responding and closing

  • When they apologiseThank you for telling me. What matters now is [NEXT STEP]. What help do you need?
  • When they explainI understand. Let me check I have it right: [WHAT YOU HEARD]. Is that fair?
  • Agreeing a fixLet us agree what changes: you will [THEIR ACTION] by [DATE]. I will [YOUR ACTION] by [DATE].
  • ClosingThank you for talking this through. Let us check in on [DATE]. If anything formal needs to happen, I will speak to HR first and tell you.

Download these examples

Or as a PDF

The same text as this page, in one file, with the gaps ready to fill in.

How to use these

  1. Do it in private. Open with one of the lines below and say the facts first.
  2. Ask the questions one at a time. Listen to the end.
  3. Agree what happens next, and write it down.

What to avoid

  • Do not bring it up again unless it happens again.
  • If someone criticised them in front of others, speak to that person separately.
  • The mistake may be serious, may break a rule or the law, may involve a complaint, or may lead to a formal warning. Check your employer's procedure and speak to HR before you meet.
  • Do not repeat the criticism in front of others. Do this in private.

Official pages. Not legal or HR advice. If a one-to-one touches a complaint, a warning, discrimination, health or a safety matter, stop, listen, say you will speak to HR and follow your employer's procedure.

UK readers: the free Acas helpline is on its contact page. US readers: see the EEOC page and your employer's HR team.

New tools and free samples by email. A few a month. Unsubscribe any time.

Follow

Handled by Gumroad. See our privacy page.

What the full kit adds

This page shows 5 of them. The kit has the rest, and the files you fill in.

The start page of the kit: One-to-one meetings
$9, one price

One-to-one meetings: agendas, questions and openers

Run a useful one-to-one meeting with someone you manage.

Who it is for
Managers who hold regular one-to-ones.
What you give it
An agenda and the questions that fit.
What you get back
Six agendas, 120 questions, 16 openers for awkward topics and a follow-up message.

Word files you fill in by hand.

Filled in by hand on 2 example cases before release. How we test.

What is in it

  • All 120 questions in 12 groups by purpose (this page shows 5)
  • 6 agendas to fill in (Word) and a note sheet
  • 16 opening lines for awkward topics, the follow-up message and a one-page guide
  • 2 finished examples, including a one-to-one after a public mistake

$9, one price, no subscription. 30-day refund. Works with no AI.

The full kit goes on sale on 6 October. Follow on Gumroad to hear when it is out.

How do I talk to an employee about a mistake?

Choose a private time soon after it happened. Say what you saw, ask for their account, listen, then agree what changes and who does what by when. Stick to the facts.

Should I raise a mistake straight away?

Usually soon, when it is fresh, but not in front of others and not when you are angry. If it could lead to a formal step, speak to HR first.

What should I not say when someone has made a mistake?

Avoid words about the person, such as careless. Describe what happened and what it caused. Then ask what they would do differently.

Should I talk about a mistake in front of others?

No. Do it in private. This is our advice.

Questions people ask

Should I talk to them in private?

Yes. Do not repeat the criticism in front of others.

What if the mistake is serious?

It may break a rule or the law, involve a complaint or lead to a formal warning. Check your employer's procedure and speak to HR before you meet. In the UK, Acas explains how employers should handle performance and conduct problems.

What do I say first?

Start with the person, then the facts: "I want to talk about what happened in [MEETING OR EMAIL]. First: how are you?"

Is this legal or HR advice?

No. It is general wording. If a conversation turns into a complaint, a warning, discrimination, health or anything formal, stop and speak to HR first. In the UK, Acas explains the steps.

More

Sources