The short answer
Would you trust and buy from this ... store?
- A cautious visitor reads the shipping and return terms before paying. If they are missing, unfinished or contradict each other, that is a reason to leave.
- In 15 stores whose owners asked why they had no sales, 4 had a shipping or refund policy that was missing, thin or template text, and 3 had a shipping policy link that returned a not-found page.
- One store's policy still said "Orders are processed within [2-10 business days]".
- In the 100-store study, product pages at 45% of 99 stores did not clearly state both shipping and returns.
- We saw these on public pages. We cannot say they cost anyone a sale.
Counts are from our look at 15 stores whose owners asked for feedback (public pages only, 4 October 2026) and our 100-store study (99 measurable, 3 October 2026). The owners picked themselves and 15 is a small number, so read the counts as direction. They are gaps we saw, not proven causes of lost sales: we could not see anyone's traffic, ads or checkout.
What to check, in the order the evidence showed it most often
- Shipping and return terms on the product page itself
In the 100-store study 45% of 99 stores did not clearly state both; in 15 owner-posted stores 14 had no shipping or return details in the hidden product details Google reads.
How to check: On a phone, open a product page. Find the delivery cost, delivery time and return window without opening the footer. Add a one-line note near Add to cart if they are missing. - Policy pages with real content
4 of 15 owner-posted stores, 27%, had a missing, thin or template policy. In the 100-store study, of the 70 stores whose shipping policy we could read, 21 had little or no real content. Of the 72 whose refund policy we could read, 4 did.
How to check: Settings, then Policies. Read the shipping and refund pages as a shopper: is there a time, a cost, a carrier, a return window and who pays for return postage? - Template brackets and placeholders
One of 15 stores had "[2-10 business days]" left in its shipping text. Shoppers read that as unfinished.
How to check: Open each policy page and use the browser search for "[" and for "your store". - Footer links that work
3 of 15 stores had a shipping policy address that returned a not-found page. Two of them did state shipping on the product page, which softens it but leaves the footer link broken.
How to check: In a private window, click every policy link in the footer and on the cart page. - Policies and FAQ that agree
Not a count: in a forum thread an answerer found the FAQ and the formal refund policy giving different return deadlines. In another, a waitlist FAQ still said "first batch is expected in October" while the product was on sale. We saw this pattern in 3 threads.
How to check: Put the return window side by side: refund policy, FAQ, product page, and the checkout. Do they all say the same number of days?
Questions store owners ask
Does a no-refunds policy protect me?
No. Merchants answering a forum thread said a blanket "no refunds" invites chargebacks. A clear policy the buyer saw at checkout is useful evidence if there is a dispute, but an unreasonable one is not a shield. See the chargebacks page.
Where do I edit my policies in Shopify?
In your Shopify admin go to Settings, then Policies. If you started from a template, replace every placeholder with your own times, costs and carriers.
Do I need the policies on the product page as well?
Our data cannot say it raises sales. It does show that many stores do not state them on the page: 45% of 99 in the 100-store study. A one-line note near Add to cart saves the visitor a trip to the footer.
How do I check that my policies agree?
Read the shipping and refund pages, the FAQ, a product page and the checkout side by side and write the numbers down: processing days, delivery days, return window. They should match.
Is there a free checker?
Yes. Our free Shopify Policy Checker finds missing or conflicting details across your policy pages. It works as a text you paste into ChatGPT or any chatbot.
Free help for this
- Check your store policies for gaps and mixed messages: Finds missing or conflicting details in your refund, shipping and privacy pages, and suggests wording.
- Gather the evidence for a chargeback: Got a chargeback? The proof to gather for your reason, what you already have, and where to find each piece in Shopify.
Optional: let ChatGPT do it for you
Press the button, open ChatGPT and paste. The copied text is a set of instructions for the chatbot, so you do not need to read it. Then type your details and send. You do not need this for the checklist above.
Want me to look at your store?
Send your store address and what you are seeing. We read the public pages of your store and send back one page of findings, free, with no call and no sign-up. We do not need access to your admin, and we cannot promise a day.
Kai Ventura, Pro Skill Packs
More questions in this series
- Why do I get traffic but no add to carts on my Shopify store?
- I have a Shopify store and no sales yet. What should I check first?
- Visitors but no sales: the overview
- What we found in 15 stores, the full study
If you want a tool for one of the jobs above, the six Shopify helpers are in the Handle the weekly jobs in a Shopify store: six workflows, $29. Pro Skill Packs is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by Shopify Inc.